Showing posts with label drama. Show all posts
Showing posts with label drama. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 9, 2010

The White Ribbon

I'll make this one relatively brief, mostly because it's so hard to know where to begin. Watching Haneke's films I always feel like I'm being taunted by a being whose intelligence is far greater than my own. His films are incredibly open ended, leaving some viewers claiming that there are no answers, while some claim with positivity that they know just what he was aiming for (check out the imdb boards). To me, Haneke is brilliant. He's the only director I can think of who is a master of visually storytelling, yet manages to make a movie, purposefully eliminating what other filmmakers would consider key scenes, only to have the film turn out better for it. In the White Ribbon, there is a masterful play of show and tell. Haneke makes choices that might be completely wrong in the hands of someone less capable.

Haneke manages to straddle some elusive barrier between subtlety of message and overtness. I mean, it's a morality play shot in high contrast black and white; that's pretty blatant metaphor. Also, it deals with the oppressed children in a German rural township who will grow up to be the Nazi generation. Yet, there's a profound deepness to his work, and i think it somehow hearkens back to what he chooses to show and what he doesn't. He doesn't condescend to his audience by handing them the answers on a platter. His films reflect a world where there are no easy answers.

The movie depicts a period of time, about a year in length, in which a serious of increasingly violent crimes are committed. Almost every single one happens off screen; we only see some of the aftermath--a body, a boy crying. Rather than cutting within the scene, Haneke tends to position the camera, then having his subjects walk in and out of the frame. Once in a while he will pivot the camera to follow them, but the camera remains stationary. He uses this method in the powerful scene depicting the punishment of two of the priest's children. They enter a room at the end of the hall, closing the door behind them. The camera rests, statically, and gradually we hear the sounds of whipping issuing from behind it. It has been said of Haneke that he likes to test the modern audience and its desire to witness violence acts; therefore, he deprives them of that pleasure. Here, denying us access makes the punishment even more shaming. The rest of the missing scenes work in a different way, because we are able to imagine any number of people executing the crimes. And forcing the audience to use their imagination in this way, makes even us possible perpetrators.

In another scene, the school teacher (Christian Friedel) witnesses one of these children, balancing tenuously on the railing of a bridge. The teacher anxiously yells for him to come down; the child claims, inscrutably, that he gave God a chance to punish him, but God didn't take the chance, so he must want him to live. Likening his parents, the highest authority he knows, to God, creates the oppressive state of ignominy leading to his and the other childrens' sociopathy. Throughout the film, we bear witness to the adults' hypocrisy. Their adulterous and incestuous crimes go unpunished, while the children are tied to their beds to prevent masturbation, or beaten for staying out too late (although what we are meant to assume they are doing might be deserving of such a punishment, or worse).

Did the children commit these crimes? Probably, yes. But Haneke, as he has done in the past, implicates everyone in these violent occurrences. Directly or indirectly, nearly everyone is responsible.

(image the first)
(image the second)
(image the third)

Sunday, September 6, 2009

Moon


I was basically obligated to see Moon, because it was directed by a fellow alumnus of my undergrad school. Although, Duncan Jones has been in the alumni category a decade or so longer than me. He was famed, previous to his first feature length release, for being the son of David Bowie. This was buzzworthy at my school. It is rare that celebrity children end up in the philosophy department of small town Ohio--Wooster, OH, to be more exact, and of all people, David Bowie's son. But no matter whose son he had been, I probably would have have thought, "of all people!" I guess that's the way it goes.

Anyway, it doesn't matter whose son he is. He clearly has a talent all his own, although reviews of this film will probably have a hard time separating his subject matter here from the aura of his father. Jean Renoir probably had the same problem when he was starting out.

In Moon, Sam Bell (Sam Rockwell) is up on the eponymous cratered orb harvesting something or other, because it has recently been discovered to be a solution to Earth's energy crisis. He is approaching the end of a three year stint, completely alone except for the robotic GERTY, who is placidly voiced by Kevin Spacey. GERTY is a fairly brilliant creation, in my opinion. He seems immediately archaic, big and bulky like the first models of computers. Though his voice reveals nothing about his emotions (if he indeed, has any), he has a screen on which an emoticon pops up to accompany his dialogue and give it an emotional spin. GERTY's initial interactions with Sam introduce a philosophical discussion of what exactly makes us human. Advanced as GERTY is, and as much as we view him as a character, he is programmed. Throughout the film, he displays only about five emotions, and most of the time he is either happy, sad, or perplexed. GERTY's emotions begin to mirror Sam's as he is thrown into the turmoil that results from meeting oneself.

...Zounds! Yes, Sam does meet himself. As it turns out, Sam is a clone of the original Sam. His memories are implanted. When our Sam's succeeding clone is awakened too early, the two come in contact with one another. What follows is sort of a fascinating character study and analysis of human nature. By inserting the original Sam's memories, they replicate him exactly. Or do they? While their life experiences differ only by three years, this distance is enough to mollify Sam I into a mellow, albeit moderately deranged person, while leaving Sam II erratic and angry. The two begin to acknowledge their shared memories, and still they act as individuals. What we are left to question is whether every Sam evolves the same way.

By setting up an army of successive clones, the regime that implanted them attempts to mechanize humanity, to program it as GERTY has been programmed. Up until a point, they practically succeed. For instance, we see Sam charting his time on the moon by drawing smiley faces on the wall that mirror those on GERTY's screen, as if his capacity for emotion is waning with only a robot's interaction. Still, as Sam insinuates, the complexities of the human mind and spirit cannot be harnessed in this way. He says something to this effect to GERTY, as he removes the "kick me" sign from his monitor. Still, the fact remains, outside of Jones construction, that much of human history has demonstrated how the human will can be pathetically weak, as often as it can be strong. We can become like machines, if we lose our self-awareness.

Like all good science fiction films, there is much more to this film than clones in space. It's worth seeing, and it has a nice score from Clint Mansell, who brought us the memorable soundtrack to Requiem For a Dream.

Thursday, September 3, 2009

The Sweet Hereafter

Now that I'm home again, I once more have access to the printed New York Times (if only on Sundays). First, I always tackle the arts section, because it feels so good to hold in my hands the kind of information I usually have to scour the interwebs for. The New York Times Arts is a great resource for film news of all kinds. I especially like how they don't discriminate between big Hollywood blockbusters and the oft overlooked works of smaller production companies, or the work of Egyptian-Armenians who were raised in Canada, as the case may be.

I wasn't familiar with Atom Egoyan, but after reading the write-up of his forthcoming Chloe, I thought I'd take a look at some of his earlier work in order to prepare myself. After reading Katrina Onstad's article noting Egoyan's penchant for exploring "Sexual taboos," "miscommunication," and "complicated puzzles... in which characters misread one another and the world, cornered by sexual desire and technology," I was intrigued. Hm, I thought. This sounds like all that I love, and more! The more I write on here, the more it might become apparent that I am drawn to remorselessly depressing and disturbing films. (If you have any suggestions, send them my way.)

I just watched The Sweet Hereafter and I was suitably impressed. This is the kind of film to which one might prescribe the term "elegiac," particularly in response to the heavy subject matter. Egoyan is not kidding anyone with the plot; there is no suspense. The film is about the aftermath of a terrible accident. Therefore, the aftermath is exactly what the narrative begins with. The opening is quite haunting, and we are confronted with a beautiful image that will not be truly explained until later, although it reveals immediately what the film is concerned with. The film opens with a long pan across dark wooden floorboards, ending with an overhead view of a family in bed--a mother and father with a young child cradled between them. This is the most unifying image of family life that is portrayed in the film, and it occurs in the first few moments. Directly following this, Mitchell Stevens (Ian Holm) becomes trapped in a carwash, a moment that suggests a parallel to the fate of the many children involved in the bus accident.


The film's narrative is fragmented, weaving in and out of the present. Throughout, Stevens attempts to extract the particulars of the accident from the townspeople in order to construct a litigation case. He is, as it turns out, a lawyer. He is also a father who has lost a child, although in a different manner. He is encumbered by a drug-addicted daughter, who calls him from payphones to beg him for money. The film explores the tracts of grief--the need to assign blame where there is none, the refusal to accept an unordered universe that claims young lives without reason.

Visually, the film is stark--set in mid-winder with bleak twilight snowscapes. The town seems like the edge of the world. Capturing his characters as distant silhouettes against this snowy backdrop, Egoyan invokes a kind of desolate loneliness that even the desperate dialogue of the grieving parents cannot render. As the bus goes over the highway barrier, the camera keeps its distance. From a distance, we watch as the bus slides onto a thin layer of ice, slowly sinking in.

To me, the pinnacle of this film is Sarah Polley's performance as Nicole Burnell, the angelic teenager who is the sole survivor of the crash. Opposing her performance is Ian Holm as the wily and world-weary lawyer. Add a haunting soundtrack, mostly sung by Polley herself, and you have a powerful, lingering vignette of the most innate human characteristics. I can't wait for Chloe.

Saturday, August 29, 2009

Taking Woodstock


Ang Lee's Taking Woodstock has garnered rather mixed reviews. But regardless of reviews, this movie is destined to succeed, because its target audience is the nostalgic and the envious, all of them revved up for this 2 hour romp into the romantic past. In these reviews, several misdemeanors are cited, including poor performances and general dullness, but the most ubiquitous criticism is that there is no concert to be seen. Yes, anyone who was helplessly hoping to relive the concert through Lee's camera lens will be sorely disappointed. I'll admit, part of me was hoping for this as well, but let's be honest. Why bother? Why bastardize the memory of three days of peace, love and music by commercializing them into a mainstream film? Perhaps this would have been apt, given the subject matter Lee explores, but I, for one, am just as happy he didn't try.

This not a film about Woodstock so much as it is about the climate of the 1960s. Not that I was there or anything, but I think in this regard, Lee does a fine job. Even while Lee takes moments to rejoice in the free spirit of the times, an undercurrent remains of all of the things the hippie movement attempted to circumvent, but could not inevitably avoid. Lee's film portrays a subtle criticism of the 1960s climate that mostly falls into a dichotomy between the communistic idealism of the hippies and the unavoidable capitalistic leanings of those who stood to benefit from the concert. At the outset, these two forces collide as Michael Lang (Jonathon Groff) and his company attempt to make a monetary deal that will allow the Woodstock concert to continue. These free-spirited flower children create an oasis amongst the conservative townspeople who threaten to evict them.


The whole movie represents Elliot's journey. He begins as an outlier, and is soon baptised into the 60s culture. This journey becomes literal as he moves from his parents home into the crowd of beaded, muddied, peace toting young people. The baptism becomes literal as Elliot takes acid for the first time and emerges from his tent in full-on hippie garb. In one of the several scenes depicting the long, crowded walk to the concert fields, Lee's camera swings over the makeshift stands that have been erected by the road, food stands and the like, all trying to capitalize off the concert by charging for corn and lemonade. Once he reaches the fields, however, everything is communal. Capitalism and selfish motives are forever nipping at the heels of freedom and love. Elliot's movement serves as a pilgrimage, but it is inevitably an aborted one. He never makes it to the mecca, the concert itself, though he tries several times. He remains on the edge, halted by drug-use and mud-bathing. In the end, it is the electric current running through the mire that prevents Elliot from finishing his journey.

By the end, the idealism in the film has run out. The vision we are left with is a muddy, abandoned field. "Beautiful," Michael notes, as the camera takes in the apocalyptic view. He then tells Elliot to follow him to San Francisco, where he alludes to having his hand in preparations for the notorious Altamont concert. There is a detectable note of irony here, as the free-spirited youngsters seem blinded by their idealism. "Far out," the friends note.

Another theme that floats hazily through the film is the idea of perspective. As Tisha (Mamie Gummer, also Meryl Streep's daughter!) puts it, perspective is what divides us, and kills love (yes, the truth speaks). The translation of her dreamy, zen-speak is that we must find a way to combine perspectives in order to commune, to love freely. In a way, the film is all about perspective. For one thing, we are never given a perspective that will allow us to see the concert (We are treated to Elliot's acid trip, though). The split-screens, which are an homage to the documentary, also reflect on this notion. The viewer is taken a step backward, out of Elliot's view and into an omniscient one, where nudity and smoke and sexin' are rampant. These parallax views are prominent during the construction of the concert, when hopes are high. They disappear by the end of the film.

There are other elements at play here. I haven't even touched on Elliot's Jewish immigrant parents, or his homosexuality, or the Vietnam War, but I'll leave that to someone else.

This is film is flawed, certainly. But it is not lacking merit in some areas. In conclusion, this movie might not be about what you think, but I might be reading too much into it. It is something I have been known to do. Probably, it depends on your perspective.