Showing posts with label satire. Show all posts
Showing posts with label satire. Show all posts

Sunday, October 11, 2009

Quills


I owe a lot to this movie. I think it is partially responsible for shaping my taste, and helping me to realize my devotion to more deranged cinema. At the very least, it helped me realize my love of cinema that is not merely escapism, and is, in fact, too gut-wrenching and disturbing to ever be considered as such. I'm not sure I could say what made me adore this movie so much when I first saw it, which was just a little after it came out in 2000 (this would put me at about age 12 or 13). Partly, it could be the way it moves so seamlessly from the satirical into the disturbing--so smoothly that you aren't sure what happened. Now, I have seen the film so many times that it is almost more difficult to pick it apart, as I do whenever I watch a film now. Quills made a big critical splash at the time and is part of Philip Kaufman's rather impressive oeuvre, alongside his remake of Invasion of the Body Snatchers and The Unbearable Lightness of Being.


Quills
is essentially a parable about self-expression, both artistic and sexual. And every film about art usually has a confluence of the two (is art possible without sex? Is sex possible without art? Is art sex? Is sex art? Would my parents have allowed me to rent this if they actually knew what it was about?) Nearly every exchange in the movie is sexualized in some aspect; every conversation is a power-play. This is, after all, a film about the origins of sado-masochism. Madeleine (Kate Winslet, who always rules) is a laundry-maid in a mad-house, caught between two men who are completely polarized in their attributes. The Marquis de Sade (Geoffrey Rush, who usually rules) is as full of perversions as the stories he is illegally publishing from within his mad-house prison. The Abbe (Joaquin Phoenix, who is okay when he is not Johnny Cash) is pious, virtuous, and gentle, and practically effeminate as a result. He oversees the asylum residents, attempting to use varying sorts of humane therapy (painting, theatre, choir) to keep them in check. The characters abide in a subtle balance until the entrance of Dr. Royer-Collard (Michael Caine) whose reactionary methods unleash a tidal wave of suck.

Sort of reminiscent of this seminal image, no?


Long story short: Abbe's repressed sexuality eventually drives him insane, putting him into the same cell that the Marquis had previously occupied. Despite the myriad disgusting fantasies pulsing through his mind, the Marquis is, seemingly, more aroused by the process of putting them to paper. His most poignant sexual act is writing, just as Madeleine's is reading. Both sex and art are complementary functions of human individuality. Neither can be repressed without egregious results like insanity or death, at least, if you happen to live in an insane asylum in Revolutionary Era France.


Naturally, there is a lot of voyeurism as well, which brings to mind the scopophilia of cinema in general. According to Freud, scopophilia is already an erotic tendency, a fundamental part of human sexuality. Particularly when a large part of the subject matter of the film is already related to sexuality, the look becomes even more eroticized. Whether or not Kaufman is intentionally bringing this out, it remains in the subtext. There are many close-ups on key-holes and watching through holes in the wall. In one particular scene, Abbe and Royer-Collard watch the Marquis through a rectangular window in his door, while he carries on as if he is an actor caught in the middle of a screen-performance. Coincidentally, he is rehearsing the theatre group. We, as an audience, witness the many sexual scenes, unfolding in a hermetic world that is unknowing of our presence. We are made voyeurs over and over.


Upon being confronted about leaking the de Sade's manuscripts to the publisher, Madeleine describes how she placed herself in the stories, allowing herself to play out her fantasies. This moment is descriptive of human interaction with any narrative art-form, cinema included. To put oneself into a narrative is almost a sexual act in itself, as reader and writer intermingle to create something new--an experience that is unique to the reader (or viewer). Certainly, being able to enter this world for a few hours is transportative, exactly the way cinema should be.

Tuesday, September 22, 2009

The Cook, the Thief, his Wife and Her Lover

The reputation of this film precedes it, but don't assume you have any idea what you're in for. Unless, that is, you are more informed than me. Intially, I found this film extremely difficult to get into, which isn't surprising, considering Peter Greenaway's filmmaking style. His script is at turns overly verbose and totally silent, but its the wordy parts that are harder to stomach. The camera is nearly always at a discreet distance, without enough close-up shots to allow us to engage with the characters. Much of the time, the experience of this film is akin to watching a theatrical production--an analogy Greenaway seems to encourage with his relatively barren sets, expressionistic lighting, and careful attention to framing. Oh, and excruciatingly long takes, of course. Often after allowing the camera to linger, the static shot will be followed by a swift, long pan through the restaurant in which the bulk of the film takes place.


The domninant theory about the meaning of this film is that it is an allegory about Margaret Thatcher. Honestly, this is a little beyond me. And anyway, if you throw aside the allegory, there's still an awful lot going on in this film. Actually, if you go and read the imdb faqs, there's a fascinating discussion about this film and all the different theories about it. That's here.

I hate to use the world "self-reflexive" again, but let's face it; it's here. Filmmaking is not necessarily coming to the forefront, but Greenaway is clearly saying something about the nature of art, and I think, about filmmaking too. Part of the way he does this is by making the film surrealistic and painterly, as well as stage-like. Everything is blatant in its superficiality--from action that marches in time to the soundtrack, to sets that mirror Dutch paintings. Careful attention is paid to framing, and at the end, the curtain closes.


As the title might lead you to believe, the main players in this film are a cook, a thief, his wife, and her lover. Georgina, the wife (Helen Mirren) begins a wordless affair with Michael (Alan Howard) after making eye contact with him while dining in her husband's restaurant. Minutes later they have sex in the lady's restroom, while Albert (Michael Gambon) dines in the other room. The next time they do it, Georgina takes him back to the kitchen where they fornicate amongst the bread, later, the chickens, after that, a meat locker. Their lovemaking is interspersed with a few rare close-ups... of cooks dicing various ingredients, making an all encompassing comparison to violence, food, and artistry. The cook (Richard Bohringer), hovers around them innocently, and they reveal themselves to him fully, unashamed of their actions, of their nakedness. He is somewhat God-like, controlling the backstage like the director, yet also having free reign over everywhere else. At the same time, his apparent objectivity, in a way, mirrors our own perspective. Like him, we are privy to all the information, yet we are kept at a discreet distance, not able to engage, and so, able to think for ourselves.

While it is hard to say what this film is truly about, certain themes are latent throughout this atmospheric drama (if you want to call it a drama). This film is filled with sex, gluttony, feces, blood, and rot. It opens with Albert and his gang beating a naked man, and smearing him with feces. They leave him in the parking lot, where he becomes surrounded by dogs. Bowed on all fours, he visually becomes one of them--an visual metaphor that defines the characters from then on. The sex scenes take place in bathrooms and amongst the food. It is humanity reduced to its most basal elements. Counteracting this is Michael's oft-noted affinity for books and higher learning. When the lovers escape, his library becomes their haven. When Albert encounters him reading in the restaurant, he notes that Michael must be the only man in the room who has read that book, but every man has read the graffiti on the bathroom walls. He grunts, "Makes you think, doesn't it?" Indeed.

Here's where the super spoilers come in, because I really can't talk about this movie without giving away nearly everything important that happens in it.

Appropriately, Albert kills Michael by shoving books into his mouth. In a jarring moment, the camera pans down from Albert and his goons to reveal Michael, bloodied and moaning on the floor. Like the pro that he is, Greenaway skims over the part where Albert tracks him down, and cuts directly to the gore. At any rate, the dichotomy between art and the physicality of life comes crashing down here as Michael's insulating books become the weapon of his undoing. Still, as much as erudition seems to be distrusted here, art provides the framework for this whole story. Clashes abound throughout the plot between artistry and raw humanity. Most characters seem to possess a little of both. Except for Albert, a monster who knows only how to tear things apart.

This all culminates in an astonishingly disgusting final sequence, which nothing can really prepare you for. Georgina has the dead Michael cooked, and forces Albert to eat him. Michael's body is totally dehumanized, turned into poultry, a soulless piece of meat. It's horrifying, and unforgettable. Finally, in a rare close up, we can see the horror on Albert's face as he becomes a cannibal.

Sunday, September 13, 2009

Ace in the Hole

Together, Sunset Boulevard and Ace in the Hole form a pair of atypical noirs--less concerned with seedy crime than they are with the beauty inherent in collapse. For one thing, this serves as a good reminder that the genre that we today call noir is just a vague list of characteristics that characterize a large number of films made from the 30s to the mid 50s. At the time, no one really knew what they were doing; mostly, they were making B movies. Anyway, when it comes to shadows and venetian blinds, this film falls short. There are no detectives in dark alleys. More often than not, the action takes place outside, in direct sunlight on the dessicated plains of New Mexico.


These sun-saturated, dusty exteriors are contrasted against the Dantian darkness within the caves that provide the opportune accident that instigates reporter Chuck Tatum's (Kirk Douglas) breaking story. Driving across the desert on an assignment from his small town newspaper, Tatum accidentally comes across a trading post where a man has been trapped in a collapsed mine. He smooth-talks his way into the center of the operation until he is pulling all the strings. When Tatum enters the mines, there is no need for shadows. Wilder uses the caked dust on his face to the same effect. The capitalistic criticism is overt; Leo (Richard Benedict) is trapped when he goes too deep into the mountain in order to find an artifact that might be worth something. Tatum, in turn, exploits him totally.


With its subtle traces of self-reflexivity, this film forms a sort of set with Sunset Boulevard's backstage Hollywood noir. The tall-tales Tatum spins become the reality for the people flocking to the desert; he is a constructor of the truth. This is also interesting in light of the fact that Ace in the Hole was the first production for which Wilder operated as producer and director, giving him the escalated creative control that he had been seeking. In some shots, the crane that lifts Tatum up onto the cliffs is very much like the type of crane used to lift the camera and director for a bird's eye shot. As Tatum stands atop the cliffs looking down at the flock of gawkers below, it is not hard to imagine Wilder in his place, uttering directions through the megaphone. With all the inner frames of the film, Wilder also seems to be giving consistent references to the framing lens.

The setting of the film, in combination with the use of deep focus and wide angles creates an equation for some compelling and memorable imagery, which it delivers. When Tatum stands over the ant-like crowd, the camera reveals his power over them. My favorite moments are when the camera sweeps over the crowds that have convened for the literal "media circus" that ensues. The build-up to this "circus" is intriguing as well. It starts with an almost unnoticeable passing of balloons in the distance and soon becomes a frenzy.